Picture: Sean Gallup/Getty Images
Now that we have established the good that can come from solar power, are there downsides to solar farming?
There are, but they can be managed if clarity, transparency, and community buy-in is emphasised, according to Tyndall’s Professor Brian Norton.
“They do need to be near the grid, you obviously cannot be too far away from that. They are not suitable for sites where the amenities rely on visual quality. That rules them out,” he said.
With any technology where you are consuming land, there are competing options for that land, said Mr Norton.
“The obvious one being farming, and other use also. In terms of the analysis, those things need to be viewed very, very clearly, although it should also be said that in farming, there is set aside where land is not used anyway, as it were.
“The nature of the land tends to be on land where there is not another productive use anyway.
“But nevertheless, in terms of the appropriate selection of sites, the environmental impact, wildlife, alternative uses, and so on, all need to be taken into account thoroughly.
A sheep grazes at a solar farm in Sonnewalde, Germany. Counterintuitively, solar panels are less efficient in higher temperatures, meaning Ireland’s temperate climate could be optimal for the clean energy. Picture: Sean Gallup/Getty
“That also should be, and is a requirement in Ireland, subject to appropriate public consultation.
“Solar power is a different resource than wind, although they do complement either, by the nature of its operation. It is silent, which is another important attribute.
“There is that visual factor, if you don’t like the look of them, so a particular location is important in terms of amenity. That needs to be taken fully into consideration when it comes to location,” he said.
A clear regulatory environment rather than interventions down the line — as has been the cart-before-the-horse approach taken by Irish authorities in the past — would go a long way towards assuaging concerns.
“It is better to have a clear regulatory environment to do these things that everyone has to follow, rather than being driven by incentives that are selectively made available to the particular people who happen to get them.
“It does need that proper regulatory environment, such as how on a technical level you send the electricity to the grid. Environmental legislation exists already and things such as environmental impact assessments can be applied directly across.
“One of the interesting things is that it is a technology that is going down in price. If one makes a particular measure that you agree to buy the electricity at a certain price, that needs to have a mechanism for keeping it under review. That margin could increase if future systems are installed, at that same price, despite prices going down. That has happened in some places previously. The regulatory environment needs to be dynamic, have good disclosure around what prices are.”
One of the interesting things about PV (photovoltaics) is the durability, often they are signed up on contracts of a fixed duration to pay back the costs of the system, according to Mr Norton.
“People who are buying the electricity from the installation and over so many years are paying back the cost of installation.
“These are well-designed and well maintained, incredibly durable systems, so that at the end of their lives, they can actually be producing electricity still, when all their costs have been met. The longer they can last and are properly maintained, they are properly reused where possible, and certainly recycled.”
There is a danger of disregarding the good if you are insisting on perfection, Mr Norton warned.
In other words, having too restrictive conditions on solar farming and power could mean Ireland missing the boat while other countries thrive.
“Unfortunately, this is such a fast-moving industry. There are missed opportunities if you wait for perfection.
“But I do agree that there is a need for having a clear and well-informed regulator, and that they have got very clear sense that it is a technology that will continue to decrease in price, such that while the operators have got to make a living but that there clear ways of making sure that as the prices decline, that the taxpayer is getting value for money for such a good investment — you are not paying the same price now that you might in three years time, when it is significantly cheaper.
“To be fair, some of the prices at the recent auction for the installations in Ireland are very tight, so we will see if they get built.
“But the technology is continually decreasing in price, it is just a matter of timing. The evidence is that Ireland has learned from others.”
There could be conflict between biodiversity and solar farm location, another highly-regarded expert of world renown has warned.
Yvonne Buckley, professor of zoology at Trinity College Dublin, told TDs and senators discussing the climate bill there will be trade-offs throughout the system when it comes to biodiversity.
“There will be some places where it is inappropriate to site a wind farm or a solar farm because of the impacts on biodiversity,” she said. “One of our challenges is trying to figure out where in the landscape to put these different land uses. We must examine where the best place is and where we will get the lowest amount of trade-offs between biodiversity and climate action.
“There will be trade-offs. We will not always have easy solutions but being aware of those trade-offs enables the Government to make decisions on where easy wins for CO2 and biodiversity can be found and where more difficult situations arise. It is then up to decision makers to decide what kind of trade-offs they are willing to accept.
“If we do not consider the impacts on biodiversity, however, we could go blindly into climate actions that have negative effects that are not accounted for and that limit our opportunities to put in place nature-based solutions in the future.
“It is important for it to be on the table and for biodiversity to be visible and a part of the decision-making process. We need to be able to model those trade-offs in order to understand and to go in with our eyes open on what kinds of trade-offs we are willing to accept.”
According to Housing, Planning and Local Government Minister Darragh O’Brien, there are currently no specific planning guidelines in place in respect of solar farms.
“Proposals for individual solar farm developments are subject to the statutory requirements of the Planning and Development Act 2000, as amended, in the same manner as other proposed developments, with planning applications made to the relevant local planning authority and with a right of appeal to An Bord Pleanála,” Mr O’Brien said.
“Within the wider national, and local planning context, planning authorities must make their decisions, based on the specific merits or otherwise of individual planning applications.”
He said that while he is satisfied that the planning code is sufficiently robust to facilitate the assessment of individual planning applications for solar farm developments, the matter is being kept under review, in consultation with Environment Minister Eamon Ryan, who leads on renewable energy policy.
“Our two departments are presently exploring the potential for enhancing national planning guidance on solar energy, taking account of solar energy projects being assessed by planning authorities and the scope for future development of the sector in the context of the ongoing development of renewable energy policy.
“On foot of this on-going engagement between the two departments, where the need for specific planning guidance for solar farms is identified, my department will develop such guidance as appropriate,” Mr O’Brien said.
According to the International Energy Agency (IEA), solar PV generation increased 22% in 2019 and represented the second-largest absolute generation growth of all renewable technologies, slightly behind wind and ahead of hydropower.
With this increase, the solar PV share in global electricity generation is now almost 3%. In 2019, PV generation overtook bioenergy and is now the third-largest renewable electricity technology after hydropower and onshore wind.
Despite decelerating growth due to recent policy changes and uncertainties in China (the largest PV market globally), 2019 was a year of record global growth in PV capacity, the IEA says.
As competitiveness continues to improve, solar PV is still on track to reach the levels envisioned in the SDS, which will require average annual growth of 15% between 2019 and 2030.
The entrance to the 40-hectare site in the townlands of Finnis and Mishells, north west of Bandon, Co Cork, which has been earmarked for the development of a 13.1-megawatt solar farm. Picture: Dan Linehan
The IEA says that stimulated by strong policy support concentrated mostly in Europe, the US and Japan, deployment of distributed solar PV systems in homes, commercial buildings and industry has been growing exponentially over the last decade.
“In most countries, commercial and residential systems already have electricity generation costs that are lower than the variable portion of retail electricity prices.
The increasing economic attractiveness of distributed PV systems could therefore lead to a rapid expansion in the coming decades, attracting hundreds of millions of private investors,” the agency says.
Covid-19 has led to construction delays, supply chain disruptions, and weaker investment in the PV sector, the IEA acknowledges.
“Utility-scale projects are susceptible to supply chain concerns, labour constraints and construction delays, all leading to delays in project commissioning. The distributed PV sector is more at risk as it relies on both individuals and SMEs, who are more severely affected by lockdown measures and any economic downturn resulting from Covid-19.
“Despite the slowdown expected in 2020, acceleration of PV capacity deployment is likely to continue in the medium-term, as the cost of electricity generation from solar PV is increasingly cheaper than alternatives. The rapid recovery of the distributed PV sector will depend on the pace of economic recovery and government policies.”
Despite any setbacks, electricity accounts for one-fifth of global energy consumption today, and its share is rising, the agency says.
“It is set to play a bigger role in heating, cooling and transport as well as many digitally integrated sectors such as communication, finance and healthcare. In pathways towards meeting international energy and climate goals, such as the IEA Sustainable Development Scenario, the trend will accelerate.
“In that scenario, electricity could surpass oil as the world’s largest energy source by 2040.
“Wind and solar’s share of global electricity generation would rise from 7% to 45%, with all renewables combined generating more than 70% of the total.”
IEA executive director Dr Fatih Birol is adamant that solar power is the king-elect of the 21st century.
“I see solar becoming the new king of the world’s electricity markets. Based on today’s policy settings, it is on track to set new records for deployment every year after 2022.
“If governments and investors step up their clean energy efforts in line with our Sustainable Development Scenario, the growth of both solar and wind would be even more spectacular — and hugely encouraging for overcoming the world’s climate chall-enge.”
According to the IEA outlook for energy report, solar PV is now consistently cheaper than new coal- or gas-fired power plants in most countries, and solar projects now offer some of the lowest cost electricity ever seen.
“Renewables meet 80% of global electricity demand growth over the next decade. Hydropower remains the largest renewable source, but solar is the main source of growth, followed by onshore and offshore wind,” the report last month said.
For Tyndall head of energy research Prof Brian Norton, solar power provides huge potential for jobs in local communities in Ireland.
“In terms of jobs, there is regular inspection necessary, there are components that need to be replaced. If there is arable farming around, there is grass that needs to be cut, etc. There is an industry around it.
“There is also a good opportunity that Ireland has proved itself very capable of designing and arranging systems. Ireland has led the way in regions like France, the US, and South America.
“The big picture skillset is very much in Ireland. The more you decentralise energy production, the more the generating capacity is serving the local needs.
“This could be a very good thing for Ireland, as long as the developments are sensitive to environmental issues, siting issues, etc. There are some caveats because things can be done in less than the ideal manner, but the broad picture is that they are good.
“There are sites that are well away from public routes for example, that are silent, that are south facing and near gridlines. I like the look of them, but that won’t apply for everyone. But there are ways of accommodating all parties and groups within this.”
In August, the first Renewable Electricity Support Scheme (RESS) auction saw 63 solar projects approved as part of 82 renewable projects in total.
Some are community-led.
JP Prendergast, chairman of the Claremorris and Western District Energy Coop, said: “We are so proud to be putting a solar farm, which is 100% community-owned, onto what was once a dumping ground — turning it from a brown site to green.
“We hope we, in partnering with Mayo County Council and working with Community Power, can provide a model to other communities for what can be achieved.
“The big win for us here, because of RESS-1, is that it has given us credibility and empowered us. We can now show other communities just what is possible.”
Solar energy accounted for approximately 34% of the overall auction energy volume, the majority of this portion was awarded in the technology neutral category with solar energy proving very competitive, according to the Department of Communications, Climate Action and Environment.
Chair of the Oireachtas committee on rural affairs, Denis Naughten, said seven community-owned renewable energy projects in Kilkenny, Galway, Mayo, Wexford, Clare, and Cork, would produce electricity for 10,700 homes.
They include five solar projects.